Operations

Respond to negative reviews on Airbnb and Booking.com: 10 reply templates and when to get a review removed

By Matteo AnzideiPublished 11 min read
Respond to negative reviews on Airbnb and Booking.com: 10 reply templates and when to get a review removed

In short

To respond to a negative review, thank the guest, acknowledge the specific point without arguing, say what you fixed and close with a line for future guests: 3–6 sentences, no personal data. Your reply won’t change the rating, but everyone about to book will read it. A review can only be removed if it breaks the platform’s rules or, for rentals located in Italy, the requirements of Law 34/2026 (for example, if it was posted more than 30 days after the stay); a genuine but harsh review stays, and your reply is the tool you have.

Problems solved during the stay don’t become reviews€9.99/unit a month until Dec 31

Why reply to a negative review at all?

When you reply to a bad review you are not talking to the guest who wrote it: they have already made up their mind. You are talking to the next guest, comparing your listing with three others and scrolling to the lowest reviews to see what could go wrong. A calm, specific reply tells them that problems, when they happen, get taken seriously and fixed.

Airbnb’s own Resource Center says a short, friendly public response reassures other guests, and recommends thanking the guest and sharing how you are improving. On Google a reply has one more effect: the reviewer gets a notification and can still edit the review after reading it. On Airbnb and Booking.com the rating stays as it is, so the reply is mainly for future readers.

If you run a rental in Italy from abroad, reviews are also how you prove that the place is well looked after when you are not there. The wider playbook is in our guide to managing an Airbnb in Italy remotely.

The 4-step reply

  1. 01

    Thank them, without filler

    One line: “Thank you for taking the time to write, it helps us improve.” Avoid pasting the same text under every review; readers notice.

  2. 02

    Acknowledge the specific point

    Name the issue (the shower, the noise, the door code) and, if it’s true, apologise for the inconvenience. If a fact is wrong, correct it calmly with something verifiable, without accusing anyone.

  3. 03

    Say what you did about it

    This is what convinces readers: “we replaced the mattress”, “the arrival guide now has photos of the main door”. If you fixed it during the stay, say when and how.

  4. 04

    Close for the next guests

    One useful line of context and your name. Skip “come back and see for yourself”, which reads as a challenge.

What to write and what to avoid in a public reply
WriteAvoid
3–6 sentences, in the language of the reviewPoint-by-point rebuttals
The specific problem and the fix“No other guest has ever complained”
Verifiable facts (times, repairs, listing photos)Accusations, sarcasm, personal remarks
Your name and a host’s toneThe guest’s full name, documents or booking details
A reply within a few days, once you’ve cooled downA reply typed in anger the same evening
A reference to rules already in the listingThreats of reports, fines or legal action

10 reply templates for negative reviews

Replace the placeholders in square brackets and adjust the tone to your listing. Each template works on Airbnb, Booking.com and Google.

1. Cleanliness
Thank you for flagging this, and we’re sorry the apartment wasn’t up to standard when you arrived.
We’ve gone through the [bathroom/kitchen] with our cleaning team, and every turnover now ends with a checklist and a photo check before the next arrival.
Cleanliness is non-negotiable for us. Thank you for helping us get it right.
[Host name]
2. Street noise (outside your control)
Thank you for describing your stay.
The apartment is on a lively street in the historic centre and weekend evenings can be loud. We now say so clearly in the description and leave earplugs in the bedroom.
Guests who prefer quiet will also find our courtyard-facing room in the listing.
[Host name]
3. Difficult check-in or a code that didn’t work
We’re really sorry about the wait on arrival; after a journey it’s the last thing you need.
The [keypad/lock] had a fault that was repaired the next day, and we’ve rewritten the access instructions with photos of the entrance and a back-up number that is always on.
Thank you for your patience that evening.
[Host name]
4. The place didn’t match the listing
Thank you for pointing this out: the listing should say exactly what you’ll find.
We’ve updated the photos of the [bedroom/kitchen] and made clear that [the sofa bed is in the living room / the bathroom has a shower only].
Guests booking from today know exactly what to expect.
[Host name]
5. Value for money
Thank you for your honest feedback.
Prices change with the dates: during your stay there was [event/trade fair] in town and rates across the area were higher than usual.
We’ve still added [amenity or service] and reviewed the kitchen equipment so every night is worth its price.
[Host name]
6. A fault fixed during the stay
Thank you for telling us straight away about the water heater.
The technician came the following morning and, for the inconvenience, we [refunded one night / offered a free late check-out].
We’ve since replaced the system, so it won’t happen again.
[Host name]
7. A review with inaccurate facts
Thank you for your feedback. For future guests: [breakfast was not included in the booking / the parking listed is a paid garage 200 metres away].
We’re sorry expectations were different and we’ve made this clearer in the description.
[Host name]
8. A guest who broke the house rules
Thank you for your review.
Our house rules, shown in the listing before booking, include [quiet hours from 10 pm / a maximum number of guests] out of respect for our neighbours in the building.
We apply them to everyone in the same way, which is also why our guests always find a quiet building.
[Host name]
9. Low score, positive comment
Thank you for the kind words about the location and the apartment!
If something made you choose a lower score, do let us know: we read every suggestion and act on it.
[Host name]
10. Reply in Italian to an Italian guest
Grazie per il feedback, e ci dispiace che [il riscaldamento / il Wi-Fi] non abbia funzionato come doveva.
Abbiamo [sostituito il router / fatto revisionare la caldaia] e aggiunto istruzioni chiare nella guida della casa.
I prossimi ospiti lo troveranno sistemato. Grazie per averci aiutato a migliorare.
[Host name]

What never to write in a reply

  • The guest’s personal data. No full names, phone numbers, emails, documents, health details or booking specifics. Booking.com’s guidelines ask explicitly to leave other people’s personal data out, and in Italy you hold guests’ ID details for the police registration, not for publication.
  • Retaliation or threats. Airbnb doesn’t allow reviews written in retaliation and forbids threatening a bad review to get compensation. The same spirit applies to replies.
  • Offers in exchange for removal. Offering a discount or refund to get a review deleted or changed is prohibited by Airbnb and Google, and Italy’s Law 34/2026 makes a review that results from discounts, benefits or other advantages unlawful.
  • Arguments about the stars. Airbnb states that a review isn’t removed just because you disagree with the rating.
  • Promises you can’t keep. If you write “we’ve replaced the mattress”, the next guest must find a new mattress.

When can a negative review be removed?

Only in specific cases. Each platform has its own rules, and a genuine but harsh review almost always stays. This is what the official pages say (checked on 19 November 2026):

Grounds for removal and how to ask, by platform
PlatformCan be removed if…Usually stays if…How to ask
AirbnbIt’s irrelevant or not based on a real stay; it involves extortion, incentives or pressure; it’s from a competitor; it’s retaliation after a reported policy violation; it breaks the Content PolicyYou disagree with the stars; it mentions things outside your control (e.g. a noisy area); it states a subjective opinionRemoval request with reason and documents; decision usually within 48 hours; up to 2 requests per review
Booking.comDangerous, hateful, violent or sexual content, personal data, spam or deceptive practices; a reservation that wasn’t stayedIt’s a negative but relevant opinion, even a strong oneReport to Booking.com; content its algorithms flag goes to moderators, who aim to decide within five business days; reviews can also be removed after publication
GoogleIt doesn’t reflect a real experience; it’s paid or incentivised; it comes from a conflict of interest (competitors, staff, relatives)It describes a genuine, even negative, experienceReport the review from your Business Profile or Google Maps

On Airbnb, if you request a removal, wait for the decision before replying publicly, so you don’t leave a reply under a review that is about to disappear. If the request is turned down, reply using the 4-step structure.

Italy’s Law 34/2026 on online reviews

If your rental is in Italy, articles 18–22 of Law 34 of 11 March 2026 (in force since 7 April 2026) cover online reviews of restaurants and tourism businesses located in Italy, accommodation included. Four points matter for hosts:

  • When a review is lawful (art. 19). It must be posted within 30 days of the stay by someone who actually used the service, be relevant, and not result from discounts, benefits or other advantages offered by the business or its intermediaries. Two years after publication it is no longer lawful. A review backed by the tax receipt for the stay is presumed genuine.
  • The right to report (art. 19(2)). The property’s legal representative, or a delegate, can report reviews that don’t meet these requirements to the platform to have them removed, through the notice mechanism of the EU Digital Services Act (art. 16 of Regulation (EU) 2022/2065).
  • Bans (art. 20). Buying and selling reviews, likes or interactions is prohibited, including between businesses and intermediaries. Italy’s competition authority (AGCM) enforces it.
  • Not retroactive (art. 22). The rules don’t apply to reviews published before 7 April 2026.

Replying to positive reviews

Use fewer words. One personal line of thanks, one detail from the review (the neighbourhood, the terrace, the restaurant tips) and a goodbye. You don’t have to reply to all of them: prioritise long reviews, reviews that mention a specific service and reviews in languages other than yours.

Reply to a positive review
Thank you so much, [Guest first name]! We’re glad you enjoyed the terrace and the trattoria tips.
We hope to welcome you back to [City] soon.
[Host name]

To ask every guest for a review in the same neutral way, use the review request in our guest message templates.

After the reply: turn criticism into fixes

Airbnb names accuracy and cleanliness among the most common reasons guests give fewer than 5 stars. Reading bad reviews one by one is for replying; reading them all together every quarter tells you where to act.

Recurring complaints and where to act
Recurring complaintWhere to actResource
Cleanliness, hair, bathroomEnd-of-turnover checklist with photosAirbnb cleaning checklist
House rules discovered on arrivalClear rules in the listing, accepted before check-inHouse rules template
Arrival hassleOnline check-in and access details sent on the dayOnline check-in
Missing information during the stayA house guide guests can actually findWelcome book template
Slow repliesCoverage in the evening and at weekendsAI guest messaging

Frequently asked questions

Should I reply to every negative review?

Yes, to every review with a concrete criticism. The reply doesn’t change the rating on Airbnb or Booking.com, but future guests read it and see how you handle problems. Reply within a few days, once you’ve cooled down, in 3–6 sentences: thanks, the issue acknowledged, the fix, your name.

Can I ask a guest to change or delete their review?

You can contact them to clear up a misunderstanding, but you can’t offer anything in return: discounts, refunds or other benefits to change or remove a review are prohibited by Airbnb and Google, and for rentals in Italy Law 34/2026 makes a review that results from benefits unlawful. On Google the author can edit the review after reading your reply; on Booking.com, guests must contact customer service to edit a review.

How long does Airbnb take to decide on a removal request?

Airbnb says it reviews the request and emails its decision, usually within 48 hours. You can submit a removal request for the same review up to twice. If the review complies with the policy, it stays and a public reply is your best option.

Is a review posted two months after the stay valid?

For the platform it may be: Booking.com accepts reviews up to three months after check-out. For properties located in Italy, though, Law 34/2026 treats a review as lawful when posted within 30 days of the stay, and the property’s legal representative can report reviews that don’t meet the requirement. The rule is recent, so get legal advice if you plan to report reviews regularly.

Can I use the guest’s name in my reply?

The first name already shown on the platform is fine for a friendly greeting, especially in replies to positive reviews. Don’t add anything else: surnames, contact details, documents, exact dates or booking details are personal data. In replies to negative reviews it’s safer to leave the name out too.

What if the review makes false accusations?

If the content breaks the rules (for example, there was no stay, or it contains threats or an attempt at extortion), request removal and wait for the decision. If the review stays, reply by correcting the fact with something verifiable and without accusing the guest: readers reward calm, not winning the argument.

This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. Rules change and local regulations vary: check with your accountant or a professional before acting.

Sources

  1. Airbnb — Authentic and reliable reviews (review policy)
  2. Airbnb — Reviews basics
  3. Airbnb — Remove or dispute a review
  4. Airbnb Resource Center — How to handle a bad review
  5. Booking.com — Guest reviews standards
  6. Booking.com — Guidelines and standards for reviews
  7. Booking.com — Content verification and enforcement
  8. Google — Prohibited and restricted content on Maps
  9. Google — Manage customer reviews (Business Profile)
  10. Gazzetta Ufficiale — Law 34 of 11 March 2026 (arts. 18–22, online reviews)

About the author

Matteo Anzidei · Founder of Maurice Assistant

Matteo Anzidei founded Maurice Assistant in Milan to take repetitive work off hosts and property managers: guest messages, check-in, documents, Alloggiati Web and payments. He writes practical guides on short-term rental rules and automation.

LinkedIn

4.9/5 · loved by 500+ property managers

Problems solved during the stay don’t become reviews

Maurice follows each guest from online check-in to departure: it answers 24/7 in their language, handles the unexpected and involves you only when needed.

  • Free demo on your own properties
  • Guided setup by our team
  • No annual contract

Offer until December 31, 2026: €9.99 per unit a month, excl. VAT

Get your free demo

We'll call you back within one business day and show you Maurice on your own properties.

By submitting this form you agree to our Privacy Policy. We will never share your data with third parties.